Lambda Expression v/s Anonymous Inner Class - Java 8


Lambda Expression is new feature of Java 8. Before Java 8 Anonymous Inner Class was very useful to provide method local implementation of any interface like ActionListner or EventListener etc. With Java 8 if the interface is a Functional Interface we can use Lambda Expression to provide implementation.

Both of these can implement an Interface but there are subtle differences between them. Following are to the point differences between them -
  1. Anonymous Inner class can implement any interface but Lambda can implement only Functional Interface, the interface with only one abstract method.
  2. Anonymous Inner Class can have state variables but Lambda Expression cannot. Lambda Expression is stateless.
  3. Lambda Expression can only access final or effectively final variables of containing method.
  4. Scope - Anonymous Inner Class creates a new scope whereas Lambda Expression does not. Lambda executes always within scope of surrounding context. To explain it better, in Anonymous Inner Class keyword this keyword refers to current object of anonymous class and super keyword refers to object of super class of anonymous class. In Lambda Expression this keyword refers to object of surrounding class and super keyword refers to super class of surrounding class.
  5. In support to above point of Scope, Lambda Expression cannot define a variable with exactly same name as variable in containing method because of same scope.
  6. In support to above point of Scope, since Lambda expression executes within scope of surrounding class, not as if implementation of interface, lambda cannot call default method of the interface. Whereas Anonymous Inner class can call default method of the interface.
  7. Anonymous Class is actually a class without name. Which means at startup, it needs to be loaded in PermGen space and verified, object instance needs to be created to call its method. Whereas Lambda expression are compiled to invokedynamic instruction.
 
Let me know if you found this blog helpful using checkbox below. Feedback, question or comments are always welcome.

Related Articles

Functional Interface - Java8
Lambda Expression Basics and Syntax - Java8

Comments

Post a Comment

Other Popular Posts

EhCache3 In Memory Caching for Performance Improvement

Image
If you are reading this you already know that caching is mechanism to store static data In-Memory for faster access and avoid expensive database calls or any kind of service calls to get the data. There are many ways to implement cache in java based applications, starting from very simple Map based caching to Apache Common JCS , EhCache , Apache Ignite , Hazelcast , Oracle Coherence and many more. Each of them have pros and cons. I will show how to use EhCache for caching implementation EhCache3 Implementation For this example you need to have following jars in the class path - <dependency> <groupId>org.ehcache</groupId> <artifactId>ehcache</artifactId> <version>3.4.0</version> </dependency> <dependency> <!-- We need this because ehcache uses slf4j for logging --> <groupId>org.slf4j</groupId> <artifactId>slf4j-api</artifactId> <version>1.7.25</version>...
Read more

EhCache3 as JCache (JSR-107) Implementation with Cache Statistics

Image
If you are reading this you already know that caching is mechanism to store static data In-Memory for faster access and avoid expensive database calls or any kind of service calls to get the data. Read my other post to learn InMemory Caching using EhCache3 . There are many ways to implement cache in java based applications, starting from very simple Map based caching to Apache Common JCS , EhCache , Apache Ignite , Hazelcast , Oracle Coherence and many more. With so many implementations available, question is which one we should go for?  If you have to choose one from multiple options best bet is to look for standard. Standard because many people have put their mind together in it, better support, examples and guide available for reference plus expect that further upgrades/changes will not breaking changes. So for InMemory cache Standard Specification is JSR-107 .  You can read about it in more detail at JSR 107: JCACHE - Java Temporary Caching API . JCache speci...
Read more

How to enable JPA eclipselink logging in WAS Liberty

Image
When this goes well, you are happy but every developer hits situation when you need more logs and details to troubleshoot issue and determine root case. It happens many times when you work with JPA and thing don't goes as you expect. You really need to look under the hood what JPA is going, what SQL statements it's generating and executing. Environment: WAS Liberty 17.0.01, JAVA EE 7, JPA 2.1, EclipseLink 2.6.3 In above environment, to enable JPA logging including SQL statements, bind parameters and transaction details do following - Add following tow properties in persistence.xml <property name="eclipselink.logging.level" value="ALL"/> <property name="eclipselink.logging.parameters" value="true"/> Add following logging tag in server.xml <logging traceSpecification="eclipselink=all" maxFileSize="20" maxFiles="10"/> Redeploy application and recycle server. All done! T...
Read more

Functional Interface - Java8

Image
Before Java 8, an interface could only declare one or more methods also known as Abstract Method (method with no implementation, just the signature). Starting with Java 8 an interface can also have implementation of one or more methods (knows as Interface Default Method) and static methods along with abstract methods. Interface Default Methods are marked default keyword. So the question is, what is Functional Interface? An interface with Single Abstract Method (SAM) is called Functional Interface. Which means -  An interface with Single Abstract Method is a Functional Interface An interface with Single Abstract Method and zero or more default methods and zero or more static method is also a valid Functional Interface. Below is a functional interface with Single Abstract Method Below is a functional interface with Single Abstract Method along with default method and static method. You must have noticed the @FunctionalInterface annotation. What does it mea...
Read more